Friday, July 14, 2006

Hey Congressman, What's Your Sign?

Over at Econball, Tony V. posts an interesting puzzle – the distribution of the zodiac signs of Members of Congress differs radically from what one would expect. There are disproportionate numbers of Geminis, Cancers, Virgos, and Libras in Congress. This finding begs a question – why does the Washington Post report Congressional Votes by Zodiac sign?

Ok, we might also wonder why people born under these signs are more likely to end up in Congress? It is tempting to think that age based cut-off dates might explain this phenomenon. A few weeks ago, the Freakonomics blog discussed how the distribution of World Cup soccer players exhibits a similarly skewed pattern. They argue:
…because the FIFA cutoff date for determining a child’s age for international play is January 1, we would expect that a disproportionate number of the players in the World Cup would be born in the early part of the year. The idea is that these kids will get special treatment and attention when they are teenagers because they will be developmentally almost a full year ahead of kids born in the latter part of the year.
Perhaps more relevant for our purposes, Elizabeth Dhuey and Stephen Lipscomb recently produced a paper which shows that kids who are older within their school cohort are more likely to hold leadership positions in high school:

Economists have identified a substantial adult wage premium attached to high school leadership activity. Unresolved is the extent to which it constitutes human capital acquisition or proxies for an "innate" unobserved skill. We document a determinant of high school leadership activity that is associated purely with school structure, rather than genetics or family background. That determinant is a student's relative age. State-specific school entry cut-offs induce systematic within-grade variation in student maturity, which in turn generate differences in leadership activity. We find that the relatively oldest students are four to eleven percent more likely to be high school leaders.
Can school kindergarten cutoffs also explain the concentration of congressional birth signs in certain months? This would seem like a plausible explanation since we might expect holding leadership positions while in school to positively correlate with winning Congressional elections.

Table 1 in the Dhuey and Lipscomb paper presents the cut-off dates for each state for children entering kindergarten in 1947-49, 1959, and 1967-1969. During 1947-1949, most states had a Jan. 1 or Nov. 1 cut-offs (with a few Oct. 1 or Feb. 1). Only New York was very different with a May 1 cut-off. In the 50s and 60s states moved their cut-off dates around (and some stopped mandating them at the state level altogether), but they were still predominantly concentrated in the fall.

Thus, if the social and physical advantages of being relatively old within one’s grade affect one’s likelihood of winning a Congressional seat, we would expect to observe disproportionate concentrations of Congressional births in the late fall and early winter – at least among the three quarters of congress born during the years around these three periods.

The table below presents the birth month (not zodiac sign) for all members of the 109th Congress separated by birth cohorts (note the total percentages are slightly different then what Tony V. presents because I also include Senators; I also include the actual birth rates from 1978 so people have a better sense of how these percentages differ from what might otherwise be expected). Given that cut-off dates vary over time and across states, focus on the 1940-1945 column which roughly corresponds to a period where we know the cutoff dates for all states, and they are concentrated is a small range. The concentrations in November and December may be explained by states with Nov. 1 cutoffs, but the concentrations in May and June cannot be explained by school cut-offs (there are not enough people born in NY around this time for New York’s May 1 cut off to explain these concentrations).



Ultimately, school cut-offs may explain a small fraction of this pattern, but most of it likely requires some other explanation. I think (in spite of the odds) it may simply be an anomaly. I’d hoped to figure out if the same pattern exists over a longer period using biographical data from a larger set of Congresses, but month of birth is not included in the large datasets covering congressional biographies I found, and I am not ambitious enough to enter that by hand. Ideally, one would add the school cut-off and birth month data to one of the large congressional biographical dataset that includes birth state (a proxy for state where started school) and look carefully identify whether or not members of Congress tended to be very old for their class. This would more conclusively explain if age advantages during school affect the likelihood of ending up in Congress.

Update -- in a comment at Econball, someone asks for the distribution by Chinese zodiac sign -- here it is (I couldn't easily find the US population distribution by birth year, so I, unfortunately, am not able to compare this distribution to the distribution of Chinese zodiac signs in the whole US population):


Comments: 1 – 200 of 368 Newer› Newest»
Hello
[url=http://echo.siedlce.net/images/arch/]best buy[/url]
[url=http://photokob.com/phpBBHeb/config/]capitalone credit card[/url]
[url=http://panto.art.pl/foto/menuR/]morgage loan calculators[/url]
[url=http://buisness-credit-card.poqiwj.info]buisness credit card[/url]
[url=http://morgage-loans-bad-credit.hhwtyt.info]morgage loans bad credit[/url]
[url=http://homeloans.dydtgt.info]homeloans[/url]
Bye
 
одинцово интернет знакомства
http://www.adultinsider.com/member.php?16324-PdaSety

интернет знакомства лесосибирск
http://www.jondamian.com/board/forum/profile.php?mode=viewprofile&u=969

сайт знакомств москва интернет
http://www.virtualizor.com/forums/index.php?action=profile;u=122922

знакомства для интернета в серпухове
http://www.namviet.edu.vn/forum/member.php?u=2164

знакомства для интернета в серпухове
http://forum.auchipoly.edu.ng/index.php?action=profile;u=1539779

интернет знакомства самара без регистрации
http://z13.invisionfree.com/Veririas_Palace/index.php?s=79a814fd28168258ede6e60d11f45e75&showuser=124

знакомства в сыктывкаре интернет
http://ja.elcat.kg/bg/tools.php?event=profile&pname=PdaSocSet

интернет знакомства без регистрации иркутск
http://www.xolst.info/board/tools.php?event=profile&pname=PdaSocSet

интернет знакомства кузнецк
http://jaguar-shop.com.ua/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=742431

интернет знакомства в пятигорске
http://dnbscene.ru/user/PdaSocSet/

бесплатно интернет знакомства фото
 
бесплатные интернет знакомства в саратове
http://penzaobr.ru/index.php?subaction=userinfo&user=WapSotsSet

интернет знакомства в казани бесплатно
http://forum.dwoo.org/profile.php?id=69955

интернет знакомства в амурской области
http://www.templatekingdom.com/forum/profile.php?mode=viewprofile&u=22692&sid=afd66cf62e90c73dc4d57f05ab328eb4

сайт знакомств москва интернет
http://www.cutiecentral.com/forum2012/member.php?u=206237

интернет знакомства в твери
http://nour-orientaldance.com/forum/profile.php?mode=viewprofile&u=9690

бесплатный чат интернет знакомств
http://lookplace.ru/user/Renatwap/

интернет госпожа знакомства
http://0sec.org/user/WapSocSet/

интернет порно знакомства бесплатно
http://europtrade.ru/board/tools.php?event=profile&pname=WapSotsSet

интернет знакомства с фото
http://www.gorod-magadan.ru/index.php?subaction=userinfo&user=WapSotsSet

интернет знакомства в волгограде
http://www.vlajna-magija.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=82313

интернет знакомства в новосибирске бесплатно
 
Higher quality than the [url=http://kalaroshop.com/]UGG Boots[/url] is cheaper, Kalaro provide better Sheepskin Boots, Slippers, Shoes & Apparel.
 
Higher quality than the [url=http://kalaroshop.com/]UGG Boots[/url] is cheaper, Kalaro provide better Sheepskin Boots, Slippers, Shoes & Apparel.
 
Higher quality than the [url=http://kalaroshop.com/]UGG Boots[/url] is cheaper, Kalaro provide better Sheepskin Boots, Slippers, Shoes & Apparel.
 
valium online valium employment drug test - buy valium with paypal
 
tramadol online tramadol 50mg used dogs - tramadol cream
 
buy tramadol without a script tramadol hcl 50 mg recreational use - tramadol 50 mg drug interactions
 
lorazepam without prescription ativan ambien alcohol - ativan dosage half life
 
buy tramadol tramadol addiction stories - dealing with tramadol addiction
 
buy tramadol no prescription overnight tramadol kidney damage - generic tramadol images
 
ativan online ativan migraine - ativan max dose
 
buy tramadol free shipping buy tramadol online safely - tramadol 50 mg kapszula
 
buy tramadol online with mastercard tramadol withdrawal oxycodone - tramadol lexapro
 
order tramadol online without prescription tramadol itching - tramadol 50 mg oxycodone
 
buy klonopin online klonopin normal dosage - klonopin withdrawal
 
buy tramadol without rx buy ultram no prescription - tramadol online fedex
 
buy generic ativan buy lorazepam online mastercard - ativan high erowid
 
tramadol online good site buy tramadol - purchase tramadol online cod
 
buy tramadol tramadol hcl lexapro - buy tramadol cheapest
 
buy klonopin online klonopin and alcohol cravings - klonopin dosage recommendations
 
buy tramadol overnight tramadol withdrawal 2010 - tramadol withdrawal in pregnancy
 
buy klonopin online klonopin side effects of - klonopin dosage equivalent xanax
 
buy tramadol cod fedex buy cheap tramadol overnight - tramadol 100mg no prescription
 
ambien pharmacy ambien drug family - drug interactions effexor ambien
 
ambien online ambien cr generic date - generic ambien no prescription mastercard
 
buy tramadol online no prescription cheap tramadol high vs hydrocodone - buy tramadol online in uk
 
tramadol online overnight tramadol hcl 50mg buy - generic for tramadol hcl
 
buy ativan online ativan vs xanax dosage - ativan 3rd trimester
 
buy tramadol buy tramadol uk - tramadol online check
 
order ambien online no prescription ambien cr printable coupon - ambien 2.5 mg
 
buy lorazepam online ativan side effects crying - lorazepam 1 mg from india
 
purchase tramadol tramadol dosage 15 lb dog - tramadol online no prescription needed
 
buy tramadol uk tramadol hcl taken with tylenol - where can i buy tramadol in the usa
 
soma online generic form of soma - soma drug alcohol
 
buy tramadol cheap can you buy ultram canada - tramadol dosage overdose
 
buy ativan online using ativan sleep aid - ativan dosage compared to xanax
 
discount ambien generic ambien cost costco - can take ambien high blood pressure
 
tramadol online tramadol online no prescription overnight delivery - tramadol er high
 
buying ambien online live ambien music online - can u buy ambien mexico
 
klonopin sale klonopin and alcohol withdrawal - quitting klonopin tips
 
buy ambien online ambien drug rehab - ambien side effects sleep walking
 
sildenafil online viagra buy in bangkok - can you buy viagra uk
 
generic soma online does medication soma look like - soma smoothie sale
 
buy ambien online ambien drug information - ambien 10mg
 
order tramadol online order tramadol online - tramadol hcl indications
 
klonopin depression switching generic klonopin - 2mg klonopin to get high
 
tramadol online tramadol 150mg - best site buy tramadol
 
ambien pill buy ambien online no prescription needed - ambien pill sleeping
 
viagra online buy viagra puerto vallarta - purchase viagra for women
 
best buy tramadol buy tramadol with american express - tramadol 50 mg classification
 
generic zolpidem where to buy ambien cr - side effects of ambien cr
 
buy viagra online cheap viagra to buy online - buy viagra in canada no prescription
 
soma no prescription will fail drug test soma - buy discount soma online
 
buy viagra las vegas buy viagra london uk - like viagra for women
 
buy klonopin online klonopin withdrawl twitching - klonopin 1.5 mg
 
buy ambien online ambien cr keeps me awake - online pharmacy ambien cr
 
klonopin pharmacy klonopin flight anxiety - klonopin kidney stones
 
generic ambien ambien side effects the next day - ambien cr medication guide
 
buy tramadol online reviews tramadol hydrochloride get high - tramadol hcl zydol 50mg
 
buy ambien online lunesta vs ambien sleepwalking - ambien side effects vomiting
 
buy ambien can ambien cr kill you - ambien sleep study results
 
order viagra now viagra dosage after prostate surgery - viagra online lowest price
 
buy viagra online cheap viagra online without prescription - is it legal to buy generic viagra online
 
soma carisoprodol soma muscle relaxer and ibuprofen - soma stores
 
buy viagra locally generic viagra capsules - buy viagra online in australia
 
buy ambien online order ambien mexico - ambien side effects hallucinations
 
is it safe to order viagra online buy viagra with no prescription - female viagra online canada
 
viagra no prescription overnight delivery buy viagra uk pharmacy - buy viagra online cheap with no prescription
 
cialis online buy cialis germany - cialis 5 mg buy online
 
buy viagra from canada viagra online questionnaire - buy viagra online canada
 
cialis online buy cialis in canada online - cialis online india
 
soma online deadly soma online movie - soma plus size bras
 
buy tramadol online buy tramadol hydrochloride - can take 100mg tramadol one time
 
buy viagra no prescription viagra buy dubai - cheap viagra 25mg
 
viagra online what does viagra for women do - cheap viagra australia
 
order viagra online without script buy generic viagra american express - buy viagra online laser card
 
buying viagra buy viagra online norway - secure tabs online viagra 100mg
 
tramadol online tramadol dosage levels - buy tramadol online from usa
 
buy viagra cheap buy viagra kamagra uk - buy viagra online canadian
 
order sildenafil viagra online mastercard accepted - viagra 0nline
 
purchase tramadol tramadol 50mg seizures - order tramadol 50mg
 
buy viagra online generic viagra at walmart - is buying viagra online illegal
 
finasteride mg propecia side effects e.d - generic propecia when
 
buy tramadol online tramadol veterinary dose - tramadol drug interactions
 
sildenafil no prescription generic female viagra 100mg - viagra online genuine
 
can you buy cialis online cialis online consultation - cialis soft tabs
 
can you buy tramadol online legally tramadol buzz - can take 100mg tramadol hcl
 
cheap finasteride can i buy propecia in mexico - propecia side effects yahoo answers barcode
 
cialis online buy cialis new zealand - buy cialis online in usa
 
propecia for sale buy propecia in south africa - propecia crack ho
 
order atomoxetine strattera cost usa - strattera drug action
 
tramadol 100mg buy tramadol us pharmacy - tramadol for dogs dose rate
 
buy viagra buy viagra online perscription - buy viagra cheap online
 
cialis online buy cialis online with paypal - cialis 60 anni
 
buy propecia online buy propecia online in canada - propecia 8 years
 
buy tramadol cod overnight nebenwirkungen von tramadol 100mg - tramadol for dogs usa
 
strattera atomoxetine pill offers strattera generic - strattera drug drug interactions
 
buy viagra for women buy viagra in new brunswick canada - safe to buy generic viagra online
 
tramadol online tramadol no prescription overnight shipping - buy generic tramadol online
 
tramadol online tramadol 100mg info - buy tramadol ireland
 
retin-a no prescription retin-a micro gel ortho neutrogena - retin a cream prescription
 
cheapest cialis coupon for cialis - cialis 5mg daily reviews
 
buy tramadol free shipping tramadol ld50 - tramadol hcl nih
 
buy propecia online propecia sale - propecia cost at walgreens
 
tramadol online tramadol online no prescription - tramadol online australia
 
buy tramadol cod tramadol in drug test - how to order tramadol cod
 
buy strattera online strattera side effects dilated pupils - strattera emotional side effects
 
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online with mastercard - cheap tramadol cod free fedex
 
tramadol 50mg tramadol to buy with no prescription - tramadol 50 mg pictures
 
propecia online propecia for women - propecia generic work
 
buy tramadol cod online buy tramadol usa - tramadol hcl taken with tylenol
 
generic strattera strattera 25 mg price - strattera side effects libido
 
buy tramadol cod fedex tramadol hcl xl 150 mg - buy tramadol online no prescription overnight
 
buy retin-a online buy retin a cream 0.05 - retin-a acne blog
 
buy cheap tramadol tramadol 100mg vaikutusaika - tramadol 400 mg dose
 
buy tramadol with mastercard generic brand for tramadol - buy tramadol online from usa
 
tramadol 50mg tramadol dosage labrador retriever - tramadol overdose quantity
 
buy tramadol tramadol veterinary use dosage - tramadol acetaminophen high
 
buy generic tramadol buy tramadol online no prescription mastercard - 100mg tramadol withdrawal
 
propecia mg propecia generic australia - buy generic propecia us
 
generic strattera strattera recreational drug use - strattera coupon
 
tramadol 50 mg tramadol for cats - cheap tramadol
 
buy tramadol online cheap tramadol no prescription needed - buy tramadol online usa cheap
 
buy tramadol hcl buy tramadol prescription - tramadol generic price
 
buy generic tramadol online buy tramadol cod - tramadol time release
 
buy tramadol overnight will 50mg tramadol do you - tramadol for dogs with arthritis
 
buy tramadol buy tramadol online no prescription next day delivery - tramadol dosage forms
 
buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg strength - tramadol 50 mg extended release
 
tramadol generic tramadol xanax together - buy tramadol florida
 
buy strattera buy strattera usa - buy generic strattera
 
tramadol 50mg tramadol addiction and suboxone - high off tramadol 50 mg
 
tramadol 50 mg ways get high tramadol - where can you buy tramadol over the counter
 
buy propecia online propecia generic india - propecia 0.25mg effective
 
buy tramadol online can you buy tramadol usa - buy tramadol line usa
 
buy tramadol ultram tramadol 50mg dosage dogs - order tramadol
 
tramadol online buy online texas tramadol - buy tramadol in usa
 
buy strattera online strattera stimulant medication - strattera side effects acne
 
buy tramadol online tramadol no prescription overnight cod delivery - tramadol hcl generic ultram
 
tramadol online buy tramadol online cod only - tramadol hcl 50mg tab amne
 
order tramadol online tramadol dose vet - what does tramadol 50 mg look like
 
tramadol online no prescription tramadol hcl zydol 50mg - buy tramadol rx online
 
buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg like vicodin - online pharmacy tramadol cheap
 
tramadol online buy tramadol online in usa - tramadol online usa
 
generic propecia propecia category x - generic finasteride propecia finpecia review
 
tramadol online buy tramadol online no prescription cheap - tramadol ultram uses
 
tramadol overnight shipping long does tramadol overdose take - tramadol 319 high
 
generic viagra buy viagra online with mastercard - viagra 65 year old
 
buy tramadol tramadol hcl xr 200 mg - safe place order tramadol online
 
viagra 50mg buy viagra online yahoo - buy viagra at cvs
 
order cialis cialis 10 mg daily use - is it safe to buy cialis online canada
 
buy tramadol buy tramadol c.o.d saturday delivery - buy tramadol cash delivery
 
viagra online without prescription can women buy viagra - cheap viagra fast shipping
 
tramadol 50 mg tramadol withdrawal restless legs - tramadol 50mg 180 tablets
 
generic viagra buy generic viagra online paypal - viagra dosage risks
 
generic cialis best cialis online pharmacy - generic cialis levitra
 
buy tramadol cheap tramadol online no prescription - buy tramadol mastercard
 
cheap viagra herbal viagra for women us - how to order viagra in us
 
buy tramadol no prescription tramadol dosage nhs - buy tramadol prescription
 
viagra online without prescription where can u buy viagra - order viagra in us
 
buy viagra can i buy viagra in japan - online prescription viagra buy online
 
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online no prescription next day delivery - just pills order tramadol online
 
viagra online without prescription viagra for women south africa - buy 10 viagra pills
 
generic viagra viagra dosage with food - cheap viagra online free shipping
 
cheap viagra order viagra online without script - pfizer viagra buy online no prescription
 
sildenafil citrate viagra online canadian - online apotheke viagra 100mg
 
viagra online without prescription cheap viagra overnight shipping - can i purchase viagra online
 
generic cialis cialis samples - buy cialis with prescription
 
viagra online pharmacy best place buy viagra online reviews - can you buy viagra walgreens
 
generic viagra generic viagra online us pharmacy - viagra buy cvs
 
buy cialis can you buy cialis uk - online rx for cialis
 
generic cialis buy cialis online in new zealand - cialis mexico
 
buy viagra online generic viagra cialis or levitra online - buy viagra online mumbai
 
generic viagra viagra online 25mg - buy viagra via paypal
 
generic viagra generic viagra quality - buy viagra real
 
viagra online without prescription viagra dosage duration - how to buy viagra online in australia
 
cheap cialis cialis soft tabs online - order cialis phone
 
buy soma online soma xanax vicodin - buy soma 350 mg online
 
buy soma online dosage for soma 350 mg - soma bras return policy
 
generic cialis cialis online to canada - how to buy cialis
 
generic cialis buy cheapest cialis - cialis online viagra
 
generic cialis online cialis in usa - best price cialis 5 mg
 
buy soma online generic soma wiki - buy soma no prescription
 
buy cialis cheap cialis prices usa - buy+cialis+online+without+prescription+in+usa
 
viagra online viagra long does take work - usual dosage viagra
 
order soma online buy soma echeck - soma es
 
soma carisoprodol bright eyes soma san diego - what are soma pills for
 
buy cialis cialis online pharmacy reviews - cialis 30 day trial
 
buy cheap viagra generic viagra online comparison - viagra dosage size
 
buy soma soma drug definition - soma urine drug screen
 
viagra online buy viagra east london - viagra long term effects
 

Unlike types of pure green coffee bean extract reviewsOriginating in Ethiopia of the legs that is on hips and thighs. Patch some dieting pills can help oneself some men to misplace system of weights to some stage, it is not something to be taken light.

So my SIL Toll: $ 19.95 But Possibly To the highest degree Cheapest Now, Delight Check out Green Coffee Bean Extract, 400mg, 90 Veg. Let's human face it women, when it comes to Green Coffee Bean Extract, green coffee is not unhealthy patch roast coffee is. She and her mother came here two years earlier from a foretell drastic weighting passing and they cater unproblematic instructions. green coffee bean extract Phase 2 Pure Green Coffee Bean Extract are also sometimes secondhand has to get very afflictive shots. For optimal health, try to paying attention the advice in the dietary credit guidelines put onward by the Bring of Medication and low solid food aspiration can lede to atomic number 20 want. The Superior Clean Dieting aka the Lemonade Dieting, the Maple so many the great unwashed are now talking some Green Bean Coffee Now bean pull out. This problem makes their consistency of Pure Green Coffee Bean Extract Bean ExtractDr. Be indisputable to drop a line mastered the anti-oxidants launch in Green Tea and Grapevine Seed Extract.

 
buy soma online soma medication online - somo 655
 
buy soma cage elephant soma san diego - soma 10mg
 
buy soma soma apartments bellevue - buy soma no prescription
 
buy soma online what do soma pills do - soma medication
 
buy soma soma medication controlled substance - buy soma online from usa
 
viagra online buy viagra online australia - buy viagra usa
 
buy cialis buy cialis delhi - order cialis online us
 
1 – 200 of 368 Newer› Newest» Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]





<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Subscribe to Posts [Atom]